Jay Carter Roofing & Sheet Metal

Roofing
8003 Old Homestead Road Georgina ON L0E 1N0
Write a Review
Write a Review
HomeStars
Roofing
Jay Carter Roofing & Sheet Metal
Star Score
StarScore uses a complex algorithm which considers a company’s review ratings, responsiveness, reputation, and recency. Learn more.

78%

This is the average rating based on homeowner reviews.
This indicates how long it's been since the last review.
Low reputation means there has been review tampering or a company request to remove a review. This score is also impacted when we do not have enough information i.e: low number of reviews.
How well a company responds to Service Requests and Reviews.
Reviews by rating (past 12 months)

Reviews for Jay Carter Roofing & Sheet Metal

Average customer rating:
9.4 10 (55 reviews)

Sort by

Rockaway in Pefferlaw
Rockaway in Pefferlaw
1 review Pefferlaw, ON
10/10

New Metal Roof

We had a great experience with Jay Carter Roofing. Everything was performed in a professional manner from sales to installation. The installation crews were very courteous and would stop and answer any questions that we had. The Armadura Metal Roof looks great on our cottage and shed and we receive many compliments on a daily basis. My wife and I would highly recommend Jay Carter Roofing to our friends and colleagues. Thanks Jay for helping us find the perfect roof! Charles & Gina - Paris LeBlanc

Approximate cost of services:
$15,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Toronto, ON
9/10

Flat roof

Thanks for the flat roof work Jay. It’s not easy to find expertise in flat roofs in Toronto and were happy that the work on our roof was completed to our satisfaction.

Approximate cost of services:
$11,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Lily in Brampton
Lily in Brampton
0 reviews Vaughan, ON
10/10

Great work at a great price!

-Great service and finished product
We shopped around for a while before we found Jay Carter. They were recommended to us by our next door neighbour and had also been hired to do the roof across the street from us. The roof next door was from two years prior and she was still thrilled with the product. The roof across the street was done while we were deciding who to go with. We got to see first hand how hard and efficiently Jay Carter's crew works. We chose them for our own home and they did an amazing job on both our roof and eavestrough. Our house was done May 2019.

-Family Feel
Jay Carter Roofing is a family run business and it shows in the best possible way. They do not try to oversell anything and focus on giving you the best product for your specific home.

-Great Price
They provide quality workmanship at very competitive prices. They were one of the lowest prices of the companies we called but had a consistent track record of good work. Some of the other lower prices had some mixed reviews. Jay Carter cost less without sacrificing on quality.

We will absolutely be recommending Jay Carter to our friends and family!

Approximate cost of services:
$5,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Pickering, ON
10/10

New Metal Roof

The Jay Carter Roofing crew have completed our roof. They were so committed to their work, respectful of our property and gave attention to every detail. The roof is even more than we expected. It has given our home great curb appeal. Even better, with the weather patterns becoming more extreme, we will never have to roof again. No more shingles to be blown off. No more roof leaks. We now have peace of mind. We plan to leave the Jay Carter Roofing sign on our lawn for a good while. We want other people to be as pleased as we are with the workmanship and quality of work.

Approximate cost of services:
$25,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Newmarket, ON
10/10

Roof and evestrough

My husband is a contractor on say the job was well done.We had hard working roofers and everything was kept neat and tidy in the yard.They needed to resheet a part or the roof and it didnt delay the compleation of the job buy much time. THANK YOU, Jay Carter Roofing

Approximate cost of services:
$8,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

We are glad that you enjoyed your experience with our company. We do our very best to keep our customers satisfied. Thank you for your kind review.

gamesman in Mississauga
gamesman in Mississauga
1 review Pefferlaw, ON
10/10

Roof Raplacement

I had a roof on a rental property that was leaking and required replacement. Jay Carter was willing to do the job even though other contractors were not willing to work that late in the year. The job was completed in one day with minimal inconvenience to the tenants. The workmen were professional and left the site free of nails or refuse.
Robert kept me well informed on the scheduling of the work, as well as explaining the warranty. Overall, I am satisfied and would recommend the company.

Approximate cost of services:
$5,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Roofing emergencies happen all year round, even in the most inconvenient times. We do our best to get to emergency jobs as soon as possible, weather permitting of course, so that the damage doesn't get worse.
We are glad that you were satisfied with our team members and a recommendation is the biggest compliment we can receive. Thank you.

Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Markham, ON
10/10

Roof inspection

I had Jay over to look at my roof before purchasing my home. He was a pleasure to work with. I would recommend him and his company to anyone who needs this type of job done. Well done Jay! Two thumbs up.

Approximate cost of services:
$200.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

We are glad that you enjoyed your experience with our company. We appreciate your recommendation.

PStojano in Brechin
PStojano in Brechin
2 reviews Brechin, ON
10/10

Metal Roof Installation

Jay worked personally with me for several weeks to select the right product, color, step by step process, what to expect and finalize the contract with pricing. He and his crew did an excellent job to install a very large and sloped roof with metal shingles from Edco. The installation was done very well with the crew laying out their materials to not impact moving in and out of my driveway . They also cleaned up every day to make sure there were no nails or shingles or anything loose around that could blow around. The installation was done in October, which was very weather challenged with rain and wind (I am on the east side shores of Lake Simcoe. Despite all the bad weather, they planned their work days and always had my house protected from the rain or wind. He provided me constant updates (with pictures) as I am not at the house through the week. They finished the job as promised. Very happy with my roof with many people asking about it. I highly recommend Jay Carter Roofing.

Approximate cost of services:
$60,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

We are glad that you enjoyed your experience with the Jay Carter Roofing team. We appreciate your recommendation. It was a pleasure doing business with you.

Mindful Home Solutions inc. in Pefferlaw
Mindful Home Solutions inc. in Pefferlaw
1 review Pefferlaw, ON
10/10

Great job

Shingles kept blowing off with these crazy storms. I Needed a more permanent solution. Price shopped with a bunch of companies for a metal roof and Jay Carter roofing gave me the best quote and more important they had the highest warranty. The work was done at the exact time that we had agreed upon. A+!! I would highly recommend.

Approximate cost of services:
$20,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Thank you. We do our best to start and finish jobs on-time. Sometimes the weather does delay jobs, but we are glad that wasn't the case with your home.

Elena in Bradford
Elena in Bradford
1 review Bradford West Gwillimbury, ON
10/10

Knowledgeable and Respectable Repairman!

The Jay Carter Roofing team did a great job repairing my roof! I had a ceiling leak in my kitchen and they came the next day to fix it. The repairman that came over to my home was very knowledgeable and respected my property. We were worried about the rain that was starting the next day, so they came and did the repair just before the rain started. I will recommend Jay Carter Roofing to any of my friends and neighbours.

Approximate cost of services:
$1,500.00
Was this review helpful?
Company Response

Thank you Elena. It was a pleasure doing business with you. We appreciate your recommendation.

The reviews on this page are the subjective opinion of the Author and not of HomeStars Inc.

More about Jay Carter Roofing & Sheet Metal

Jay Carter Roofing is a family-owned, full-service, roofing and contracting company that has been serving the GTA for more than 10 years. We operate with a staff of 35 professionals and we're still growing. We hold regular educational seminars for our installers so their skills and knowledge will always be ...
Company profile information is not moderated by HomeStars. Ask the contractor to verify before hiring.
Looking for Roofing pros in Newmarket?