Jay Carter Roofing & Sheet Metal

Roofing
8003 Old Homestead Road Georgina ON L0E 1N0
Write a Review
Write a Review
HomeStars
Roofing
Jay Carter Roofing & Sheet Metal
Star Score
StarScore uses a complex algorithm which considers a company’s review ratings, responsiveness, reputation, and recency. Learn more.

78%

This is the average rating based on homeowner reviews.
This indicates how long it's been since the last review.
Low reputation means there has been review tampering or a company request to remove a review. This score is also impacted when we do not have enough information i.e: low number of reviews.
How well a company responds to Service Requests and Reviews.
Reviews by rating (past 12 months)

Reviews for Jay Carter Roofing & Sheet Metal

Average customer rating:
9.4 10 (55 reviews)

Sort by

Gayle in Toronto
Gayle in Toronto
2 reviews Richmond Hill, ON
10/10

Roof Replacement

When I choose vendors to complete work for me, I try to choose those with a solid performance record, that is validated by 3rd party reviews. I try to complete my due diligence, asking a lot of questions, comparing what is and is not included between various vendor quotes and ensuring that I am making an informed decision, especially in this case, on something so important, as the replacement of my roof. Service and Warranty is far more important to me than price, although price, of course, is up there as well. I was very impressed with the high marks attained by Jay Carter Roofing, their attention to detail & follow up, as well as their professionalism, courteousness and that they did what they said they would do … which is sometimes rare. Before I decided to award the contract, I wanted to ensure that Safety and strict compliance with PPE, including harnesses, was adhered to. The Team didn't disappoint. The 4 star warranty is awesome. Jay Carter Roofing get top marks from me. I would, and in fact already have, recommended their service to neighbours who've inquired. It has been a pleasure to work with Jay Carter and his entire Team, both in the office and on Site. Well done!

Approximate cost of services:
$12,935.00
Was this review helpful?
CC in Sunderland
CC in Sunderland
0 reviews Sunderland, ON
10/10

Roof replacement-Shingles

Quoting and installation was a seamless process. Installers where here on time and worked nonstop to finish the job.

The courtesy of laying down tarps and running a magnet around to pickup lose nails was appreciated.

Thank you for the job well done.

Approximate cost of services:
$7,800.00
Was this review helpful?
Kyle in Newmarket
Kyle in Newmarket
0 reviews Newmarket, ON
10/10

Replacement Roof

I was impressed by Jay Carter roofing for a number of reasons:

1) Jay took the time to visit my home, answer my questions honestly, show me samples, inspect my attic, etc. He provided a very detailed quote with several options to consider.
2) Given the severity of my leaky roof, he expedited scheduling the work to occur in a matter of 2 days despite the cold and snowy conditions
3) The crew was courteous and respectful while they performed the work
4) The roof was replaced without incident and I feel like I have a quality roof that I can trust for many years.

I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Jay Carter Roofing to anyone!

Approximate cost of services:
$9,200.00
Was this review helpful?
Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Toronto, ON
9/10

A unique and challenging request for Jay Carter

We gave Jay Carter Roofing a very complicated & unique request. We were attempting to build a "passive-style" house and there were some very specific requests that had to be fulfilled, this included where and where not to drill and secure the roofing. Jay and his crew were able to lay the roof with out much trouble. They did a clean job and we are quite happy with the roof. When we had requests or questions they were dealt with. The window sills and flashing were even more of a challenge due to the thicker than normal walls we built. Jay personally came in to get these done as the original material supplied by the window company was not working with our house. Jay custom built the flashing and sills and despite the headache we gave him he came through. We've been working with Jay for a long time as this project has been much more complicated than we had hoped, with different trades coming in and dealing with city red tape but we are quite happy with the resulting metal work. Thanks Jay

Approximate cost of services:
$60,000.00
Was this review helpful?
C. Smith in Pefferlaw
C. Smith in Pefferlaw
1 review Pefferlaw, ON
10/10

Roof Replacement

Amazing!!! From the beginning, to the end of our project every aspect of working with Jay Cater Roofing was amazing. Before putting any prices together Jay inspected our roof, inspected our attic, and even reviewed our eavestrough with me. He listened to us and gave us options. Even more amazing is his team of installers. Top quality people who care about everything they do. His team even built a small “hut” over our BBQ to protect it from any falling debris. During our installation there was a huge rainstorm, resulting in a small leak in our home. Jay’s foreman was at our house 25 minutes after I called Jay! The foreman explained the issue and fixed it immediately. I feel Jay Carter Roofing has an amazing product. The difference is his team and the effort they put in to look after the customer and their satisfaction.

One of the top 2 contractors we have had work on our house, and I would have no hesitation to hire them again or recommend them! Thank you Jay and your team!!!

Approximate cost of services:
$0.00
Was this review helpful?
sonia pisarek in Georgina
sonia pisarek in Georgina
1 review Georgina, ON
10/10

Flat Roof

I have used Jay Carter Roofing several times over the past years and have always found Jay and his team professional, reliable with great workmanship. Jay and his team replaced and completed a flat roof just in time for the change of season which was greatly appreciated. jay realized the roof needed immediate attention and was on the job immediately. I have recommended Carter Roofing to many of my neighbours and all have been extremely pleased with the outcome and the fair and honest pricing. Thank you Jay and your team for excellent work and attention to detail.

Approximate cost of services:
$3,000.00
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful?
Dave in Newmarket
Dave in Newmarket
1 review Toronto, ON
10/10

Roof shingle, eaves and downspouts

Decided to go with Jay Carter roofing after receiving multiple quotes. Their price was fair and they offered a great product (after reviewing the different types of shingles that other companies offered). Also liked the fact it was a family owned business that was local and had been around for almost 20 years. After agreeing to the work, the roof was completed within a week! Crew was great and they cleaned up throughly. Overall a great experience. Great job, fair price and all completed in a timely manner. Would highly recommend them.

Approximate cost of services:
$12,000.00
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful?
Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Mississauga, ON
10/10

Roofing Replacement

Jay and his team were great. Jay spent the time with us and answered all of our questions. The job was done in a professional manner, everything was cleaned up well and the final result looks great. We've already recommended Jay to our neighbours and think that anyone who chooses them to replace your roof will be quite happy.

Approximate cost of services:
$9,700.00
Was this review helpful?
Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Pefferlaw, ON
10/10

Roof and eavestroughs replaced

Jay Carter replaced the shingles and eavestroughs. Jay kept in close communication throughout the process and the crew did a professional job. The property was left tidy and all plants and outdoor furniture were cared for. A quality job. The work was done as scheduled in a timely manner. Roof looks great.

Approximate cost of services:
$12,000.00
Was this review helpful?
Mitch in Newmarket
Mitch in Newmarket
0 reviews Newmarket, ON
8/10

Roof Re-Shingle

Roofing quote was delivered quickly and professionally. Price was competitive. Work was carried out efficiently with due respect to safety and quality of execution. Crew were friendly and professional. No collateral damage to landscaping and house and clean up was well done

Approximate cost of services:
$9,000.00
Was this review helpful?
The reviews on this page are the subjective opinion of the Author and not of HomeStars Inc.

More about Jay Carter Roofing & Sheet Metal

Jay Carter Roofing is a family-owned, full-service, roofing and contracting company that has been serving the GTA for more than 10 years. We operate with a staff of 35 professionals and we're still growing. We hold regular educational seminars for our installers so their skills and knowledge will always be ...
Company profile information is not moderated by HomeStars. Ask the contractor to verify before hiring.
Looking for Roofing pros in Newmarket?